John,

Yes, the problem lies in that some take it literally. Therefore, they will insist that everyone agree to it when being examined as Elder or Deacon as to whether they are in agreement with the WCF.

As for me, I do not take it literally, yet it is there. The question becomes should we take it literally. If not, then should it be required for someone in the examination process to list their non-literal view of it as an exception. Since there is only a few churches that sings psalms only, then most of ordained men would would be considered outside of the WCF. That is why I say the phrase has caused, and is causing all kinds of consternation within Presbyterian bodies.

Although some will be in disagreement, I think that someone can be fully within the system as taught in the WCF without ascribing to every minor detail.


John Chaney

"having been firmly rooted and now being built up in Him and established in your faith . . ." Colossians 2:7