You know, Pilgrim, this reminds of something that I've always had in the back of my head. You and the guy who runs the anti-type to The highway (http://www.eternalsecurity.us - don't forget their discussion board) shoudl get together for an online debate. It could be conducted over e-mail, with everything being subsequently posted on both boards on a locked thread. I don't know the likelihood of such an event happening, but I think it'd be great.

(Latin phrase goes here.)