Dear Pilgrim,
(changed comment, and subject)
If I have come across too strong on this matter of Sola Scriptura, it is
not because I completely reject it. Rather, I defended Sola Scriptura boldy on multi-denomonational (open) forum (for quite some time) and needless to say; I am not as confident now, as I was back then.
I am sure you have read the work of Robert Bowman. I am going to read what you have linked. (today) I am going to give you a link to a current discussion : Defining the doctrine of Sola Scriptura by Robert Bowman started in August 2006. It is top of the list, at the moment, in the Bible segment to the BIOLA forum Apologetics.com
Defining The Doctrine Of Sola Scriptura(an ongoing debate since August 2006)
Earnestly,