I am at present reading Poythress' "God Centered Biblical Interpretation". On the back cover of the book is a recommendation by DA Carson. Also, somewhere on this site I also read that Monergism Books is recommended and when you read how they select their books then you get the impression that they sell books from trustworthy authors in the reformed tradition. So, one of the books is DA Carson's "Exegetical Fallacies" which is highly commended on Monergism Books. However, when searching the web for DA Carson you also come across negative criticism about DA Carson. See for example

http://www.wayoflife.org/fbns/bewareof-da-carson.html

For example, the following is said:

Quote
D.A. Carson is not a man that fundamentalists should be following. He walks in the most radical of New Evangelical circles, being associated with organizations such as Christianity Today and the Evangelical Theological Society (ETS), both of which are deeply compromised theologically. Christianity Today has been one of the chief voices for New Evangelicalism for 50 years. It has promoted everything from Billy Graham to Fuller Theological Seminary to Robert Schuller to Karl Barth.

and

Quote
Do the fundamentalists who are distributing Carson’s book agree with these things? Those fundamentalist schools that are selling Carson’s book in their bookstores and recommending it to their students, are they also warning about Carson’s apostasy?

The book refered to above is not "Exegetical Fallacies" but "The Inclusive Language Debate".

This is rather confusing. Can anyone shed some light for me on DA Carson in particular but also more generally on which authors are really trustworthy in the sense that they really
follow the reformed tradition.

Johan