Originally Posted by AC.
Funny thing Pilgrim is that the article you recommended by Schreiner is the one that is taken to task, look over the article I linked when you get the chance.

Don't get me wrong - Predestination/Perseverance of the saints does not fall with corporate election - but again, the case is being made that when Paul speaks of election it is in a coporate sense. I'm not saying this guy is right about Romans 9 stricly speaking of corporate election alone - I think God's soveriegnty is obviously on display and I would disagree that there is no reference to individual salvation at hand but this article that somebody linked to me did blindside me somewhat.

I think you are mistaken about Schriener's article that Pilgrim recommended being the article Brian Abasiano took him to task for. If you look carefully at Schreiner's article again, you will see the following words:
"A Response to Brian Abasciano"

Tom