After reading this dialogue, patricius79's arguments sound remarkably similar to the discussions I have had with JWs.
Just to mention one discussion that I had with a JW.
I believe he was reading from a Watch Tower. He said something to the effect that if one was stranded on a deserted Island and only had one book, they would be better off with Watch Tower material (can't remember the exact wording) than the Bible, because they would not be able to understand the Bible.
The person went on to tell me that there are only 12 people with in all the world that can rightly interpret the Scriptures, that is why they distribute material such as the Watch Tower.

Tom

Last edited by Tom; Mon Dec 07, 2009 10:11 PM.