The Highway Forums General Discussion Theology Discussion Forum Covenantal Succession

Does he merely believe in the false doctrine of presumed election? At best I would say it is very confusing what he embraces. The majority of your reply is answered below in my reply to Pilgrim. And, please do a search on this subject as it was discussed several times before you ever arrived on this board and you are making judgments without all the facts.

IMHO I was being very gentle knowing the history of this topic probably a little more than you do. I was not being ungentle in asking RonD about his children for him and I discussed this issue in another thread named "Infant Baptism." I was not being ungentle there, I was allowing him to gently remember the posts there and how IMHO he had been cornered by the Scripture on "this" very issue.

You may desire to also ask yourself, "Is being gentle always the way our Lord rebuked error?" Though IMHO it is not applicable in this instance, it too is not always a valid form of an argument against false theology.