Dear Joe,<br><br>It is incorrect to assume that Revelation 22:19 speaks of only loss of rewards as 1 Corinthians 3:15 does. I don't seem to recall writing anything about the tree of life pertaining to salvation; the warning in this verse indicates a debarment not only from the tree of life, but from the holy city as well, which as you correctly pointed out, is something that a heretic forfeits (I am assuming that you believe a heretic cannot be a saint). But how can a man forfeit what he does not have? To have a right in the holy city, he would have to be written in the Lamb's book of life (Revelation 21:27), to have his name written there, he would have to be one of the elect (I draw this by implication from Revelation 13:8). So then the warning in vs 19 stands for the elect as well -- and it does pertain to salvation.<br>This makes guaranteed perseverance of the saints and unconditional election impossibilites.<br><br><br>In Christ,<br>Josh